Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Sebastian's. We'd love to have your feedback!

Caledonia, WI

Type to search our menu...

You are submitting your information to Sebastian's and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. Popmenu's and apply.

Our Latest Reviews

Bill about 1 month ago

*Tuna Tataki

So delicious we order it every time we dine at Sebastians.

Mary 2 months ago

Roasted Beef Strip Loin

The short ribs are one of my favorite Friday night specials. The meat is tender and flavorful, the Chianti wine sauce is a perfect combination with the meat.

Mary 4 months ago

Flounder Florentine

The flounder presentation is just the start of a very nice dinner experience. The flounder was cooked perfectly, and the spinach and red peppers didn't in anyway overpower the delicate flavor of the flounder. Highly recommend to those who enjoy whitefish.

Jim 5 months ago


I had the sword fish special tonight. It was great! Probably the best I've had since being in Malibu several years ago. Would definitely order it again. We love everything about Sebastian's. Staff is great, server is great and it's the only place we go. Management very accommodating to our requests. It feels very comfortable.

Jim 5 months ago

*Tuna Tataki

Excellent! Delicious! We would order it again without a thought.

Julia about 2 months ago


Unbelievably good -cooked to perfection.

Mary 2 months ago


Very tasty, well prepared. I wasn't real sure about the pimenton sauce as I had never had it, but it added just a little flavor to the dish and wasn't overpowering at all.

Mary 4 months ago

Guinness Braised Short Ribs

The braised short ribs are always excellent. Tender and flavorful, I'd like to see it added to the regular menu.

Jim 5 months ago


My wife loved it! Great dinner!

Annkulas 11 months ago


Wonderful dish! So glad I chose it. Great waitress!